Podcast

EP04 / Meta’s 805 million euro peek at your camera roll, and Fnac learns that apps have cookie rules too

Italian Garante fines Meta 805 million euro over camera roll access in the Facebook app, and the CNIL fines Fnac 7 million euro for tracking in its mobile app without consent.

EP04 / Meta’s 805 million euro peek at your camera roll, and Fnac learns that apps have cookie rules too
Photo by Zeg Young / Unsplash

Two recent decisions, one Italian and one French, rest on the same simple rule: what sits on your device is yours, and reading it or writing to it takes consent unless it is strictly necessary for the service you asked for. Simple, right?

The Italian Garante applied that rule to Meta and landed on a 805 million euro fine. A Facebook feature on Android suggests photos and videos from your camera roll as ideas for posts. Access came through a single app-wide permission, introduced by a murky notice about “enabling other features”, and the feature was on by default. Someone is losing Consent bingo! The Garante logically treats the smartphone as terminal equipment under e-Privacy, so the access itself is a problem, whether or not anything is transmitted or anyone is harmed. Meta’s attempt to send the case to Ireland went nowhere, because e-privacy has no one-stop shop. Nice try though.

The CNIL’s 7 million euro fine for Fnac, triggered by a NOYB complaint, is the quieter of the two but just as instructive. There is no cookie banner drama here. The Fnac app was sending a user identifier and the products people viewed to a third-party domain via an API, to personalise recommendations and train the algorithm behind them. Neither purpose is strictly necessary to provide the service, so consent had to come first.

Also in this episode: a Microsoft 365 outage that took a hotel’s email-based safety alerts down with it, the cold chain hacks that left European supermarkets in shock, the ICO’s new guidance on AI-generated access requests, Ofcom’s decision to leave client-side scanning out of its online safety rules for now, and the growing hype around wearables that record everything, everywhere.


audio-thumbnail
CLEARTXT EP04
0:00
/2946.42034