Nearly 4 million people ticked a box agreeing to marketing “from our partners”. One of those partners turned out to be a large French media company nobody had mentioned, and which had never bothered to provide information on this switcheroo of personal data. The French CNIL decided that was not what proper consent looks like and fined that company 600,000 euro. The company appealed, the marketing trade bodies rallied round, and the whole thing ended up in Luxembourg. The Advocate General (AG) has now given his view in preparation of a judgement, and it goes to the heart of how lead generation and data brokering work in Europe. Tim unpacks the reasoning, the argument the marketing industry lost, and some nuances in the AG's opinion.
Before that, Bart takes a fine of 2,400 euro and turns it into a question worth considerably more: what makes you a controller when your contract says processor? The CJEU has been incrementally answering that for years, and the answer lands uncomfortably close to home for anyone building or buying AI models (which, let’s be honest, we all are). If you decide what the data is used for, it may well be your problem now.